HAIR CARE DESK · UNITED STATESHOW TO DECIDEEDITORIAL CHECK · 2026-08-26
STRAND REPORT

Claims, context, and what the bottle leaves out.

DECISION DESK

How to document color retention

How to document color retention

12 SOURCE REFERENCESOWNED USE TEST NOT EXECUTEDU.S. ROUTINE CONTEXT

THE DESK'S CALL

The headline.

Our method: count color runoff and scalp comfort together
02

ON THE RECORD

What keeps the headline honest.

This is an editorial conclusion from the stated context. It is not a claimed product trial, diagnosis, or universal ranking.

Decision change

Defines a reproducible way to document color retention while marking missing data instead of filling the gaps by inference.

Evidence boundary

pH, cleansing strength, deposits, friction, breakage, color retention, and scalp measures are rarely provided with comparable methods.

03

What could overturn the headline.

THE COUNTER-CASE

  • A result without the matching protocol, product version, or test conditions must remain NOT_OBSERVED or INCONCLUSIVE.

STILL UNREPORTED

  • pH, cleansing strength, deposits, friction, breakage, color retention, and scalp measures are rarely provided with comparable methods.
04

BUSINESS DESK

Commercial disclosure

This report contains no affiliate link or paid product placement. We do not turn manufacturer statements into owned findings, and we do not imply a product was used when no dated hands-on protocol exists.

EVIDENCE TRAIL

What the sources carry — and what the desk decides.

The linked sources support product status, labeling, or professional boundaries. They do not prove the editorial winner and they do not stand in for an owned test.

EDITORIAL JUDGMENT

Our method: count color runoff and scalp comfort together

A reasoned course of action; not a product result measured by the source.
BOUNDARY OF THE CALL

A result without the matching protocol, product version, or test conditions must remain NOT_OBSERVED or INCONCLUSIVE.

pH, cleansing strength, deposits, friction, breakage, color retention, and scalp measures are rarely provided with comparable methods.

Primary and professional sources in the record

  1. Is It a Cosmetic, a Drug, or Both? (Or Is It Soap?)U.S. Food and Drug Administration
  2. Cosmetics Labeling ClaimsU.S. Food and Drug Administration
  3. Summary of Cosmetics Labeling RequirementsU.S. Food and Drug Administration
  4. 21 CFR Part 701 — Cosmetic LabelingOffice of the Federal Register / eCFR
  5. Hair DyesU.S. Food and Drug Administration
  6. Health Products Compliance GuidanceU.S. Federal Trade Commission
  7. 21 CFR Part 740 — Cosmetic Product Warning StatementsOffice of the Federal Register / eCFR
  8. FDA Adverse Event Monitoring System (AEMS)U.S. Food and Drug Administration
  9. Hair cosmetics: an overviewMaria Fernanda Reis Gavazzoni Dias
  10. The shampoo pH can affect the hair: myth or reality?Dias et al.

Community signals — questions and language only

These non-representative discussions surface everyday language and open questions. They do not establish prevalence, safety, or product performance.

  1. How is it possible that my roots are oily but the rest is dry?u/LIA_XXX_ — Reddit r/HaircareScience
  2. My scalp gets flaky even after shampooingu/AntiqueSmile — Reddit r/HaircareScience
Data and test conditions still required
Product function and category

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Ingredient list for the current version

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Body area and directions

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Amount, contact time, and frequency

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Starting hair-fiber condition

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Performance under realistic use

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Sensory feel over time

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Tolerance protocol and stop criteria

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Regulatory status and applicable labeling

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Buildup and residue

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Hair color and color retention

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Format, packaging, and dispensing

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Standardized photography conditions

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Breakage, combing, and friction

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Evidence for the specific claim

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Instrumental measure and test conditions

Document against the current U.S. product version; keep missing or non-comparable information visibly open.

Balance scalp cleansing and lengths

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Record sensory feel after use

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Assess general tolerance with stop rules

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Separate scalp-care choices from symptoms

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Classify status by intended use and claim

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Assess buildup and removal separately

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Document color deposit and retention

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Assess dry-shampoo residue and scalp feel

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Measure hair fiber reproducibly

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.

Trace a general claim to its evidence

Define and retain the conditions, date, material, and outcome before presenting any owned observation.